Saturday, April 07, 2007

Easter in the Holy Land: Christians in the Occupied Land...& more from Miftah

News & Analysis
Easter in the Holy Land: Christians in the Occupied Land
April 07, 2007
By Samar Assad

Overview: Ahead of the Easter celebrations, Palestinian Christian non-governmental organizations (NGOs) issued a statement calling on Christians around the world to “put an end to Israel’s violation of our right to worship freely in the Church of the Holy Sepulcher.” Like all Palestinians, Christians’ freedom to worship is denied by Israeli restrictions on Palestinian movement through a network of military checkpoints, a separation wall and a rigid permit system.



News Stories
Over Half a Century Later, Deir Yassin Wounds are Still Raw
April 07, 2007
By MIFTAH

On Monday, April 9, Palestinians everywhere will commemorate the 59th anniversary of the massacre at Deir Yassin. This massacre, carried out by the Zionist Stern and Irgun gangs, headed by Menachem Begin, is considered a bloody landmark in Palestinian history because it not only symbolizes the massacre of innocent people but also the concerted Jewish effort to depopulate an entire nation to make room for another.

Full News Story More News Stories


The Land and Love


Title: The Land and Love

http://www.shammout.com/ob5-080.htm

The Coming Sun

Shammout's "In Jerusalem"

umkahlil: Saturday of Light in Ramallah

umkahlil: Saturday of Light in Ramallah

"According to Naseeb Shaheen in A Pictorial History of Ramallah "there is a church tradition that long ago, on the day before Easter, light broke forth from Christ's sepulcher."
Before Al-Nakba (the Palestinian Catastrophe), which divided Palestine, young men from Ramallah and other Palestinian towns went to Jerusalem to obtain the light...."

On Saturday, join the world in marking Palestine's catastrophe

"Every year, on about April 9 in cities throughout the world, Deir Yassin Day is commemorated in candlelight and prayer services, stories of remarkable heroism and testimonials by survivors of the 1948 massacre of some 254 citizens, one-third of them children, in Deir Yassin, a Palestinian village of 750 inhabitants."


http://www.mlive.com/news/annarbornews/index.ssf?/base/news-0/1175870569321890.xml&coll=2

On Saturday, join the world in marking Palestine's catastrophe

'Don't tell us that it's Arab society, that it's Islam'

.... "Mu'ayan Halaby, who calls himself an "Arab feminist," says there is a fear of discussing this subject because of apprehension about the rising influence of the Islamic Movement. But all of the speakers here also point an accusing finger at Israeli society, which pushes the Arabs to the margins and thereby gives the people who possess a weapon the feeling that they can impose their will on those around them. They also fault the police and the welfare institutions, which don't seem to really care if Arabs are killing one another and do not provide aid to the women who need it.

"Don't tell us that it's Arab society, that it's Islam," says Shalhoub-Kevorkian. "Don't turn it into a cultural issue. Go to Jerusalem or Haifa and you'll see how the girls are dressed. The reasons for what happened in Ramle are historical-political, not cultural." "

'Don't tell us that it's Arab society, that it's Islam'
By Meron Rapoport
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/845994.html
The image “http://www.biblepicturegallery.com/free/Pics/Sheep04.gif” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.
Rescued
This Beduin shepherd has rescued one of his flock from a ravine in the Wilderness of Tekoa, south-east of Bethlehem. He is dressed and equipped in much the same fashion as shepherds in the days of Jesus.. The long white garment is girdled with leather. The cloak, required for warmth at night, is rolled up and carried on his back. A dagger is tucked into his belt and an empty goatskin water-bottle under his arm. In this right hand is his sling, dangling below the hind feet of the sheep. The only change in equipment is the gun slung across his shoulders. On it he has tied his shoes being surer footed without these.
http://www.biblepicturegallery.com/Pictures/Herdsmen.htm

Regarding "Messages call for peace; acts display penitence"

RE: Messages call for peace; acts display penitence
http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/nationworld/bal-te.friday07apr07,0,2551575.story?coll=bal-nationworld-headlines

Dear Editor,

Indeed peace would be nice... but do we really have to make peace with racist Israel & political Zionism's generously subsidized, world wide war on the people of Palestine?

Must we really worship an Apartheid Wall and call hate security?

Do we really need to arm one religion (or another) to divide and destroy that one land so many call Holy.... all things being equal they aren't. Israel, a nation of immigrant bigots, has 'sovereign' power, an itchy trigger finger, a bad attitude plus a huge arsenal of very lethal weaponry while the persecuted and impoverished people of historic Palestine mainly only have endless suffering and just cause for complaint.

Considering the inherent cruelty of the current status quo, our prayers should be simply for Palestine and a just and lasting peace.

Sincerely,
Anne Selden Annab

Regarding "In Jordanian Camps, A Sense of Nihilism, Palestinians' Lives Colored by Disillusionment" by Anthony Shadid 4-7-2007 Washington Post

Jordan granted citizenship to almost all of the Palestinians who fled there after the 1948 war, but many residents of the refugee camps, disenchanted with politics, talk openly of a conflict that, in their view, can no longer be resolved. Jordan granted citizenship to almost all of the Palestinians who fled there after the 1948 war, but many residents of the refugee camps, disenchanted with politics, talk openly of a conflict that, in their view, can no longer be resolved.
Photo Credit: Getty Images
Related Article: In Jordanian Camps, A Sense of Nihilism, page A07

RE: In Jordanian Camps, A Sense of Nihilism
Palestinians' Lives Colored by Disillusionment

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/04/06/AR2007040602091.html

Dear Editor,

THANK YOU Washington Post, for once again noticing the Palestinians, and explaining the plight and the and suffering of the Palestinian refugees. I think your reporter,
Anthony Shadid, did an excellent job expressing the mood, and the frustrations- and the failure of secular resistance in the face of racist Israeli crimes against the people of Palestine.

Early Zionists, in using a lethal combination of religious identity and terror to shape the Jews-preferred entity we call "Israel" on top of historic Palestine, thought that the old will die and the young will forget.... the old are dying with broken hearts and the young are not forgetting.

A secular solution - starting with FULL respect for UN Resolution 194 from 1948, regarding the Palestinian refugees inalienable right of return- is the only solution.

Sincerley,
Anne Selden Annab

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/04/06/AR2007040602091.html
The Washington Post

In Jordanian Camps, A Sense of Nihilism

Palestinians' Lives Colored by Disillusionment

Washington Post Foreign Service,,,,Saturday, April 7, 2007; Page A07

...."The more than 1.8 million Palestinian refugees and their descendants in Jordan registered by the United Nations, along with hundreds of thousands of others in Lebanon and Syria, remain a sideshow to the region's more turbulent crises and wars, a 60-year-old diaspora whose permanence denies the notion that refugee status is temporary. But in conversations along the streets of Jordan's 10 camps, the Palestinians tell a story, however anecdotal, of a landscape where secular politics has withered, Islamic activism is ascendant and, perhaps more important, a sense of dejection, even nihilism, is rising, with uncertain consequences."

Regarding "Another side of terrorism in the Middle East" by Gary Field

RE: Another side of terrorism in the Middle East
http://www.signonsandiego.com/uniontrib/20070406/news_lz1e6fields.html

Dear Editor,

Thank you for publishing Gary Field's revealing column "
Another side of terrorism in the Middle East " giving US at least a glimpse of Israels' endless crimes against the people of Palestine. However I must disagree with how he defines the "conflict".

The core of this escalating mess is not about land or religion- it is about the blatant bigotry and injustice of political Zionism. Resolution depends on full respect for international law and the Palestinians basic human rights, including but not limited to the Palestinian refugees inalienable right to return.

Modern man made Israel is rock solid proof that arming religion with angst plus a full arsenal of lethal weaponry works to gain temporary power for a select group of ideologues willing to profit from ill gotten gains... but in the end only true democracy with full and equal rights for ALL will bring true prosperity.

Sincerely,
Anne Selden Annab

http://www.signonsandiego.com/uniontrib/20070406/news_lz1e6fields.html

The San Diego Union-Tribune

Another side of terrorism in the Middle East

April 6, 2007

..... "Last year, Sabatin took me on a tour of his land and told me how settlers from Bettar Illit burn and vandalize his remaining olive and fruit trees on a daily basis. As we walked through his fields, I was able to see olive and fig tree branches shorn from their trunks and scattered on the ground. I also saw several still-smoldering piles of ash, olive trees burned just that morning. “What can I do” Sabatin asked me repeatedly. I never knew what to say.

These settlers from Bettar Illit actually want Sabatin to take flight from his land. They are trying to force him to make a “choice” about whether it is worth it to remain. With enough pressure, perhaps he will finally relent and give it up.

Now, it appears that the settlement has handed Sabatin an ultimatum. Two weeks ago settlers again set fire to some of his olive trees, but this time the fire burned out of control. The firefighting unit from the settlement had to extinguish the blaze. What they did next, however, is befitting of the term Orwellian.

The governing council of Bettar Illit informed Sabatin that it would charge him 7,000 Israeli shekels ($1,600) for the cost of extinguishing the fires since they occurred on his land. This is an amount of money well beyond his means. They gave him until today to remit the money and informed him that failure to pay would result in the settlement confiscating the rest of his land. Sabatin was frantically and desperately trying to find a way to keep his land as the deadline given to him by the settlement approached. Even if he pays the amount, however, what is to prevent extortion such as this from occurring again?"

Another side of Middle East terrorism by Gary Fields...& more from IMEU

PALESTINE IN PHOTOS

Palestinian children laugh as they watch a performance by a group of clowns in the West Bank city of Qalqilia. (Khaleel Reash, Maan Images)

Another side of Middle East terrorism
Gary Fields, The San Diego Union-Tribune, Apr 7, 2007

A Palestinian man looks on as Israeli soldiers patrol near a settlement in the West Bank. (Maan Images)
The art of political language, as George Orwell observed, is to make falsehoods sound truthful and to deny voice to those without power. There are few practitioners of this art more highly skilled than the government of Israel.

As the military occupier of the Palestinian territories for the past 40 years, Israel has managed to represent itself as the beleaguered victim of terrorism in its conflict with the Palestinian people. At the same time, the Israeli government, through its influence in America, has discredited and even silenced those voices inside the Palestinian territories with a far different story about terrorism and its victims. Truth, however, is sometimes able to prevail despite the efforts of those with power to prevent truth from gaining voice.

Last August on these pages, I was able to tell such a story about a Palestinian farmer, Mohammed Abdel Aziz Sabatin. What had been happening to Sabatin, in facing daily harassment from Israeli settlers from Bettar Illit, I insisted, went to the essence of the conflict between Israel and Palestinians.

Contrary to popular mythology, this conflict is not a clash of civilizations. It is a conflict about land – and the power of one group of people to seize and control the land of another. Sabatin personifies this conflict, while at the same time his situation gives a very different set of meanings to the idea of terrorism and its purveyors.

Sabatin owns land directly next to the Jewish settlement of Bettar Illit, a town built on land confiscated in 1989 from the Sabatin family and from numerous other Palestinian families from the town of Husan. All told, about 5,000 dunums (1,250 acres) was forcibly taken from farmers in Husan to build the settlement.


Related stories






After construction, Sabatin was left with a small portion of his former property and has since tried to cultivate olives, figs and almonds on this land. In order to access his farmland, however, Sabatin now has to get a permit from the Israeli military authorities who administer the Occupied Territory of Palestine, and he must pass though the security gate of Betar Illit even though his family has owned this land for 200 years. In owning land in the shadow of the settlement, Sabatin is in a precarious predicament.

Last year, Sabatin took me on a tour of his land and told me how settlers from Bettar Illit burn and vandalize his remaining olive and fruit trees on a daily basis. As we walked through his fields, I was able to see olive and fig tree branches shorn from their trunks and scattered on the ground. I also saw several still-smoldering piles of ash, olive trees burned just that morning. “What can I do” Sabatin asked me repeatedly. I never knew what to say.

These settlers from Bettar Illit actually want Sabatin to take flight from his land. They are trying to force him to make a “choice” about whether it is worth it to remain. With enough pressure, perhaps he will finally relent and give it up.

To read the full article please visit The San Diego Union-Tribune.

Complicity when the dam breaks
Mark Zeitoun, International Herald Tribune (Apr 7, 2007)

This tragedy was due to a number of factors - limited Palestinian capacity, Israeli restrictions on the movement of people and goods, Palestinian infighting and - last but not least - donor politics.

But blame ultimately lies with those who would pen in too many people in too tight a spot. To this day, Israel besieges the territory in the name of security. The international community ignores the disaster that has encroached on all fronts in the Gaza Strip.


British football team begins West Bank tour
Maan News (Apr 7, 2007)

The team is formed of a group of British youth who have come to the occupied Palestinian territories to demonstrate their solidarity with the Palestinian people. The 'Easton Cowboys' wish to raise political awareness about the Palestinian issue, Al-Qawasmi explained. The team is concerned about social injustice worldwide and has previously visited Mexico, Morocco and Germany, amongst other countries.

Bearing responsibility for the refugee problem
Daoud Kuttab, The Jordan Times (Apr 7, 2007)

Israeli researcher Ilan Pape details what happened throughout historic Palestine in his book “The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine”. Furthermore, since its establishment, the state of Israel has totally refused to implement successive UN resolutions demanding that it give permission to refugees to return.

Israel launches Gaza raid, one Palestinian killed
Reuters (Apr 7, 2007)

Russia calls for end to Palestinian sanctions
Agence France Presse (Apr 7, 2007)

Christians gather in Jerusalem to follow in Christs' footsteps
The Guardian (Apr 7, 2007)

For the Passover holiday, which this year coincides with the Christian Holy Week, the Israeli military declared a closure on the West Bank and Gaza, severely limiting the number of Palestinians allowed across checkpoints. Permits were issued for Palestinian Christians - according to a UN report around 8,000, although they were said to be scarce.

Shopkeepers in the Old City said tourist numbers were still low. Farange Nashashibi, from one of the oldest Palestinian families in Jerusalem and owner of a souvenir shop, was particularly bitter. "Before there wasn't even room to breathe, the streets were so crowded," he said. He blamed the conflict with Israel. "There should be peace. There is no need to fight. The Israelis need to change their minds about us."

Many of those walking through the Old City said they knew or cared little about the vexed politics of Jerusalem and the Holy Land. Others were torn by their visit. Nessa O'Byrne-Healy, 64, an Irish woman resting inside a chapel at the Fifth Station of the Cross, had been troubled by Nazareth, close to the vast West Bank barrier, and Hebron, a Palestinian city in the West Bank which is divided by the presence of a few hundred Jewish settlers. "People have no idea what's going on. ...

Children mark Palestinian Child's Day with marches and shows
Maan News (Apr 6, 2007)

This article was originally published by Maan News and is republished with permission.

The Palestinian Child's Week festival opened on Thursday afternoon in the Abu Ammar hall in Bethlehem in the southern West Bank. The festival began with sport shows and theatre acts.

The shows, which were presented by Ibda' institution in Dheisheh refugee camp in Bethlehem, were transmitted live on Al-Jazeera satellite television.

Thousands of children from Bethlehem and Hebron marched from the "Statue of the Martyrs" in Deheisheh refugee camp to Abu Ammar hall.

While in Nablus in the north of the occupied West Bank, nearly 500 children participated in a march marking Palestinian Child's Day. The demonstration was organized by the Al-Qastal scout group and Al-'Oja river association; it was held in Balata refugee camp in southern Nablus.

The participants held signs calling for the restoration of children's rights, stripped from them by the Israeli occupation.

They demanded the concerned parties to pressure the Israeli occupation authorities to end its practices against children. At the end of the march the children staged a sit-in opposite the offices of the UN relief agency for Palestine refugees, UNRWA.

Haniya says US pressuring banks
Al Jazeera (Apr 6, 2007)

Under US law any foreign bank that refuses to co-operate with America in cutting off funding to Hamas could have its US assets frozen and lose its access to the coutry's financial markets.

Sneh: Settlers to be removed from Hebron building within two weeks
Haaretz (Apr 6, 2007)

In a text message sent to journalists, the Yesha Council of Settlements, which represents the settlers, said it would fight the decision.

Hebron, a frequent flashpoint for tensions between Israelis and Palestinians, is home to about 500 Jewish settlers living in heavily-guarded enclaves among some 160,000 Palestinians

****************************

The Institute for Middle East Understanding provides journalists with quick access to information about Palestine and the Palestinians, as well as expert sources, both in the U.S. and the Middle East. Need story assistance? Contact us. New to the issue? See our Background Briefings.

"The occupation of the West Bank and Gaza is only one face of Israeli racism and colonialism" Ali Abunimah


Ali Abunimah (nigelparry.net)
Ali to Bassem:

What's most notable about your reasoning (if one can call it that) is that you equate the occupier with the occupied, the settler with the dispossessed. Well, you should never forget that your occupier does not view you even as entirely human, let alone equal. As a Palestinian in the West Bank, you have no right, legally or morally, to try to trade the rights of your fellow Palestinians in exile for slightly better conditions from your jailers.

There's no evidence Israel is interested in giving you a state: it continues to invest billions in new Jew-only colonies up and down the West Bank. As you know, only one-third of Palestinians live in the West Bank. Since 1993, PLO leaders have tried to sell out the majority of Palestinians in order to try to achieve a little tinpot statelet for them to rule over in the West Bank.

The occupation of the West Bank and Gaza is only one face of Israeli racism and colonialism. Instead of trying to sell out your Palestinian sisters and brothers who live as third-class citizens inside Israel, or as refugees in Gaza, Lebanon, Syria, Egypt, Jordan or Canada, you ought to be standing in solidarity with all Palestinians.
http://commentisfree.guardian.co.uk/take_two/2007/04/bassem_eid_v_ali_abunimah.html

Bassem Eid v Ali Abunimah
Exchange, Comment is free, 6 April 2007


The Palestinian Right of Return was considered 28 March 2007 at the Doha Debates, a public forum for dialogue and freedom of speech in Qatar. Yossi Beilin, a Knesset member and Chairman of the Meretz-Yachad party, and Bassem Eid, of the Palestine Human Rights Monitoring Group, argued for the motion that "the Palestinians should give up their full right of return." Ali Abunimah, cofounder of The Electronic Intifada and the son of Palestinian refugees, and Israeli academic Ilan Pappe challenged the motion, which was rejected by almost 82 percent of the audience. The Debate will be broadcast on BBC World on the 14th and 15th of April. The following is an email exchange between Bassem Eid and Ali Abunimah published on the Guardian's Comment is free blog.

additional notes
annie's Comment No. 516569:
&
umkahlil's Comment No. 517059- "Everyone has the right to return

Simon Says The Pro-Israel Bias of NPR By FELICE PACE

It is Zionist control of American Mainstream Media and American Politicians that explains the passion with which King Abdullah attacked American Middle East policy last week. Arab leaders, like the vast majority of Arab citizens, understand that this self-censorship reflects the power exercised by American Zionists who remain firmly in control of American public discourse concerning the Middle East.

US relations with Arab societies and governments will remain troubled so long as the American Zionists remain in control of US Middle East policy. As Madeline Albright demonstrated on NPR, the Democratic Party offers no alternative in this regard. What Arab leaders and their citizens want is an American Administration capable of serving as an honest broker in the Middle East. This can not happen so long as Zionists continue to control critical aspects of US foreign policy.

April 6, 2007

Simon Says

The Pro-Israel Bias of NPR

By FELICE PACE
http://www.counterpunch.org/pace04062007.html

Friday, April 06, 2007

The stories not tragic enough to notice: Anna Baltzer writing from the West Bank, occupied Palestine, Live from Palestine, 6 April 2007

The stories not tragic enough to notice
Anna Baltzer writing from the West Bank, occupied Palestine, Live from Palestine, 6 April 2007

Two to fourteen-year-old girls in their living room where they were detained with their mother for hours as soldiers ransacked their home and planted explosives.

Today I visited my friend Dawud in Kufr 'Ain for the first time since he lost his six-month-old baby at Atara Checkpoint. It was heartbreaking to hear the details of the story from a man who just one month ago was asking me when I would come visit his family for pleasure, not just to take a report. He said there was more to Palestine than the sob stories. But today was all about grief. We watched a video of the funeral in silence, and saw Dawud's mother break down and say she couldn't take it anymore. She'd already lost two sons to natural causes, but apart from moderate and treatable asthma, Khalid had been a happy, healthy, chubby little boy.

Last time I visited Kufr 'Ain I took reports from one family after another regarding nightly incursions by the army. A 14-year-old girl told me how the soldiers woke her, her mother, and her five younger siblings (her father is working in the United States) up in the middle of the night with sound bombs, forced everyone out in their pajamas with no shoes and isolated the young girl to question her before enclosing the mother and children in their living room and ransacking the house. She said the soldiers put explosions in her room and in the family's well.

Another family told me how they were woken with sound bombs, rushed out into the cold, and then the young men were stripped, handcuffed, and lain on their front lawn before being taken to a neighbor's living room for interrogation. The neighbor's family was meanwhile locked in their bedrooms with the lights off, warned against any sound or movement.

There were more stories. Too many, in fact. Eventually I had to stop taking reports, partially because I had to be somewhere, but more because as I recorded the stories I had a sinking feeling that the incursions were simply too common, too unremarkable to catch anyone's attention. This would not be a human rights report that any legal or humanitarian organization would follow up with.

Major operations in Nablus or Ramallah make headlines, but incursions into many small West Bank villages are just a part of daily life. For example, the past two months, the army has come nightly to Marda village, throwing sound bombs, arresting men, abducting boys. They steal IDs and refuse to return them until their holders give names of kids in the village who put stones in the settler road that cuts through Marda. They spontaneously shut the village completely, preventing residents from entering and visitors from leaving. Two weeks ago soldiers broke into the house of a family with three sons. The middle son Ahmad, 19, who was studying for an English exam the next day when he heard soldiers outside, told me his story:
I left my books to go see what all the commotion was about. There were about 14 soldiers total surrounding my house, and three jeeps. Soldiers were kicking our front door and throwing sound bombs. When the soldiers saw me, they grabbed me and began to hit me. My parents and my brother Qutaiba -- he's only 13 -- tried to intervene but the army pushed my mom and dad to the ground and hit Qutaiba in the stomach. Each time my little brother tried to stand up they would punch him in the gut again, and my mother began screaming for them to stop. It seemed like each time she screamed they beat him again. Suddenly my mother began to wail and I saw that two soldiers were covering Qutaiba's face with their hands so that he could not breathe, suffocating him until his face began to turn red. Eventually they allowed him to breathe.
I asked Qutaiba what happened after that:
The soldiers blindfolded and handcuffed me and Ahmad and brought us in their jeeps to the entrance of our village. They dragged me out of the jeep by lifting my cuffed hands behind my back, which hurt my shoulders. Several soldiers beat me with their fists, bats, and guns, and then they started asking me questions about which village boys were throwing stones. I told them I was cold and sick, and one soldier said that this was nothing; he would punish me to the point of death. They took my cap and began throwing it above my head, laughing, making fun of me. After half an hour they got bored and left me to walk home. They drove away with my brother still blindfolded and handcuffed in the jeep.
Ahmad continued his story when Qutaiba had finished:
It was terrible listening to my little brother being beaten, and I was almost grateful when we drove away. The soldiers took me to the Ariel police station, where they beat me for several hours all over my body, especially in my head and temples. All the time I was blindfolded so I could not anticipate where the next blow was coming from. It was very scary. One soldier put his boot in my mouth. I asked the commander for some water and he told me to 'Go to Hell.' Suddenly one of them kicked me very hard in the groin and everything went black. The next thing I knew they were splashing my face with cold water, and when they saw I was awake they began to beat me again, accusing me of throwing stones, destroying settlers' cars, and being a member of Hamas. After four hours they finally let me go and I walked home.
Ahmad's father Rasmi cut in:
When my son came home after 1am, it looked as if he had taken a blood shower. He had to go into school the next day but his English teacher let him postpone the exam. I teach my children good values, to respect others and to never use violence. But how can they continue to be peaceful when they are constantly surrounded and threatened by so much brutality? I'd like to live peacefully with the Jewish people. They build their state, and we build ours. They take care of their children, and I take care of mine. I lived in Chicago for 15 years. I know that in America it's a sin to hit your children. Here, soldiers can hit other people's children and nobody says a thing! But even if they kill my children, I will not kill theirs. These are my values, what my parents taught me and what I teach my children.
As Rasmi spoke, a car drove by and the whole family jumped. They laughed nervously when they realized it was just a neighbor. Rasmi said the soldiers returned three days later and took Ahmad again, this time with his older brother Samiah. They blindfolded and handcuffed them, and brought them to an abandoned warehouse off of the main road. Ahmad was still fragile from his fresh head wounds, but the soldiers still beat him and his brother, first in silence, then cursing them and accusing them of harboring weapons. When it began to rain, the soldiers brought the young men outside, removed their jackets, and began hitting them again. Eventually they let the boys go, after stealing all the money in Samiah's wallet, 70 Jordanian dinars and 60 Israeli shekels. This in addition to 400 shekels that they stole from the house the first time, all together the equivalent of more than $200 (not to mention the CDs and toys that they broke when they ransacked the home). They also took the university documents that were in Samiah's wallet.

Qutaiba, a 13-year-old resident of Marda who was kidnapped, handcuffed, blindfolded, and repeatedly beaten along with his two brothers.
Hilwe, the Palestinian grandmother shot in the face by soldiers invading her village.


Although Marda villagers call us more than most, Marda's situation is far from unique. Most village's have simply given up on us. We recently met a 56-year-old grandmother named Hilwe who was shot in the face three weeks ago by soldiers hiding behind a corner in her village, Qarawat Bani Hassan. One rubber-coated metal bullet (don't let the name fool you; rubber bullets can -- and do -- kill) grazed her face, tearing and detaching a segment of her right nostril, disfiguring her and requiring 20 stitches. I asked Hilwe what the soldiers were doing in her village and she shrugged, "They come every day. It's nothing special." I asked why nobody had called IWPS to respond to the incursions and Hilwe's brother answered straightly, "What are you gonna do, take a report?"

We encouraged the family in Qarawat to call us more, but I won't blame them if they don't. How much are we really helping by writing these reports that policymakers and even most activists will never read? How much are we just creating false hope and forcing families to relive painful episodes that they'd rather forget? The best we can do is to offer our services and be honest about what we can and cannot do. We cannot bring criminals to justice; we cannot get innocent men out of jail; we cannot keep the soldiers from invading, or settlers from stealing land. Pretty much all we can do is write and look sympathetic, and occasionally remind soldiers that we are watching.

A Kufr 'Ain family whose home was invaded by soldiers and dogs. Rani (top right) was one of four brothers stripped, handcuffed, and lain on their front lawn before being taken to a neighbor's living room for interrogation.
Even our village seems to have given up on us. The jeeps still come, but nobody calls. Yesterday I heard by chance from a friend that a boy from Haris was kidnapped by soldiers because he was wearing too much olive green. They said that color is for the army. The soldiers drove him onto a quiet road between our village and Kifl Haris, made him take off all his green clothes (everything but his underwear), and left him half-naked to hitch his way back. He hid behind the olive trees until one car took pity on him and brought him some clothes.

Like Ahmad's and Hilwe's, the Haris boy's story will never make headlines. But there will always be the stories that do get out. The well-known Haaretz journalist Gideon Levy recently followed up on two of our recent reports: Dawud's baby and the 11-year-old human shield. The latter made it to the New York Times and other mainstream media, and the Israeli Army has officially stated that it intends to look into the human shields charges (meanwhile, other Israeli soldiers and spokespeople have stated that in fact the invasion "was pretty boring, we barely felt any action", and in the future "not all operations will be so careful").

It is the brave voices of Israelis like Levy who give me the most hope for a change in Israeli mainstream society. I remained stoic through dozens of human rights reports over the past weeks and months, but I finally broke down when I learned that one of those brave voices had been lost. On March 17th, Israeli linguist and political activist Tanya Reinhart died of a stroke in New York City. Tanya was a staunch defender of human rights, deeply dedicated to exposing to fellow Israelis and the world the crimes of her government against the Palestinian people. Tanya wrote extraordinary books and articles, but she also spent time on the front lines of the movement here in Palestine.

In our last correspondence, Tanya confessed shamefully that she was finally leaving Israel because she couldn't bear to remain after her country's summer bombardments of Gaza and Lebanon. She had eventually quit Tel Aviv University after her employers "made life impossible" as punishment for her political outspokenness. It hurt to hear such an extraordinary activist apologize for not doing enough -- she did more than most of us can ever hope to.

The brave Israeli voices that remain continue to be targeted: According to the Jerusalem Post, historian Ilan Pappe recently announced plans to quit Israel for the UK because his "'unwelcome views and convictions'" -- Pappe has done extensive research about the 1948 expulsions of Palestinians -- have made it "'increasingly difficult to live in Israel.'" Yet the Israeli resistance movement is growing faster than it ever has. And while some stories remain untold, others will always come out, even if it takes another sixty years. The only thing harder than speaking truth to power is covering up the truth indefinitely. Israel is fighting a losing battle. The reality of Israel's historic and present agression and ethnic cleansing of Palestine cannot remain hidden forever.

All images by Anna Baltzer.

Anna Baltzer is a volunteer with the International Women's Peace Service in the West Bank and author of the book, Witness in Palestine: Journal of a Jewish American Woman in the Occupied Territories. For information about her writing, photography, DVD, and speaking tours, visit her website at www.AnnaInTheMiddleEast.com

The Lady of Oranges

umkahlil Comment No. 517059- "Everyone has the right to leave any country, including his own, and return to his country."


DEU

Article 13, Section 2, of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights:

"Everyone has the right to leave any country, including his own, and return to his country."

http://www.un.org/Overview/rights.html

Article 5:
International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination

. . . States Parties undertake to prohibit and to eliminate racial discrimination in all its forms and to guarantee the right of everyone, without distinction as to race, colour, or national or ethnic origin, to equality before the law, notably in the enjoyment of the following rights:

(ii) The right to leave any country, including one's own, and to return to one's country;

(vi) The right to inherit
http://www.ohchr.org/english/law/cerd.htm

Article 12(4): International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights

4. No one shall be arbitrarily deprived of the right to enter his own country.

http://www.ohchr.org/english/law/ccpr.htm

UN General Assembly Resolution 3236, Subsection 2.

Reaffirms also the inalienable right of the Palestinians to return to their homes and property from which they have been displaced and uprooted, and calls for their return

http://domino.un.org/UNISPAL.NSF/0/025974039acfb171852560de00548bbe?OpenDocument

UNGAR 194, 11:

"Resolves that the refugees wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbours should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date, and that compensation should be paid for the property of those choosing not to return and for loss of or damage to property which, under principles of international law or in equity, should be made good by the Governments or authorities responsible"

http://domino.un.org/unispal.nsf/0/c758572b78d1cd0085256bcf0077e51a?OpenDocument

On Via Dolorosa, world's pilgrims gather by souvenir stalls

..... For the week-long Passover holiday the Israeli military declared a closure on the West Bank and Gaza, severely limiting the number of Palestinians allowed across checkpoints. Special permits were issued for Palestinian Christians - according to one UN report around 8,000 were given, although they were said to be scarce.

Shopkeepers in the Old City said tourist numbers were still low. Farange Nashashibi, a member of one of the oldest Palestinian familie s in Jerusalem and the owner of a souvenir shop, was particularly bitter. "Before there wasn't even room to breathe the streets were so crowded," he said. He blamed the conflict with Israel. "There should be peace. There is no need to fight. The Israelis need to change their minds about us."

Many of those walking through the Old City said they knew or cared little of the vexed politics of Jerusalem and the Holy Land. Others said they were torn by their visit. Nessa O'Byrne-Healy, 64, an Irish woman resting inside a chapel at the Fifth Station of the Cross, said she had been moved by some of what she had seen but troubled by her visits to Nazareth, close to the vast West Bank barrier, and to Hebron, a Palestinian city in the West Bank which is divided by the presence of a few hundred Jewish settlers. "People have no idea what's going on. I don't find a great sense of holiness in this city."

On Via Dolorosa, world's pilgrims gather by souvenir stalls

http://www.guardian.co.uk/israel/Story/0,,2052038,00.html

Rory McCarthy in Jerusalem
Saturday April 7, 2007
The Guardian

umkahlil: Wa Habibi: Good Friday

letters

RE: Jimmy Carter's "A viable Mideast peace plan"
http://www.iht.com/articles/2007/04/06/opinion/edlet.php

Dear Sir,

Delighted to see Jimmy Carter's letter "A viable Mideast peace plan" pop up in response to Friedman, mainly because I am a huge admirer of Carter's gentle courage and dignity, his humanitarian work (Habitat for Humanity as well as the Carter Center), as well as his wisdom in writing Palestine: Peace not Apartheid.

I applaud the unanimous 2002 Arab summit proposal, h
owever I do not have much faith in the heavily promoted Geneva Initiative, as it seems to me to be more of the same but more subtle, in blithely dismissing the Palestinian refugees basic human rights, specifically true return to original homes and lands. True return, not more forced transfer and segregation.

Israeli Apartheid is very entrenched. And the system has been rigged to only get worse as time goes by with immigrant bigots world wide freely moving into the misnamed "Jewish State",
immigrant bigots who are highly motivated, able and willing to make sure that even more Palestinian men, women and children are oppressed and pushed aside.

Sincerely,
Anne Selden Annab


****************************************

RE: Catholic church defaced with anti-Arab graffiti
http://www.detnews.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=2007704040392

Dear Editor,

Such a shame that so many myopic idiots worldwide, including right in our own back yard, freely abuse religion to spread hate... thankfully in many American communities most religious leaders, as well as the media and law enforcement agencies, recognize this type of despicable insult & crime as something to condemn.

Sincerely,
Anne Selden Annab

**************************************


RE: A Palestinian "Right of Return"?
http://www.townhall.com/columnists/column.aspx?UrlTitle=a_palestinian_right_of_return&Comments=true&ns=MichaelMedved&dt=04/04/2007&page=full&comments=true

AnneSelden writes: Tuesday, April, 03, 2007 1:56 PM
THE Palestinian "Right of Return"
well right of return is headlined!

"The issue, as always, is Arab refusal to accept Israel's existence and sovereignty. "

yup- true.... but oh well- sometimes a lousy product is just a lousy product no matter what the hype. Lots of people fell for the pet rock phase as I recall, but not everyone. So the promoters made lots of money on pet rocks, but that fad has passed and really it was a silly idea all along. However unlike the fad of Israel, pet rocks never killed anyone, nor did they make millions homeless- stateless- destitute.

Dennis Ross's Mythology Time.com Blog Posted by Scott MacLeod

The Middle East Blog, TIME

Dennis Ross's Mythology (5)

Let it be remembered that in 2007, the United States missed what may be a last chance in many years to negotiate a final peace settlement between the Israelis and the Arabs. That failure, if it happens, will keep the Middle East on boil for more years to come, leading to further bloodshed between Israelis and Palestinians, probably between Hizballah and Israel, and possibly between Palestinians themselves. In such a climate, Iran's nuclear ambitions, the fallout from the Iraq invasion and the regrouping of Al Qaeda may push us into another global crisis....[more]


**************************
comment i left...

April 6, 2007 THRILLED to see true support for peace & for the Palestinians' basic human rights - in particular actual mention of UN 194 from 1948.... however I am very wary about the Geneva Initiative, because it sounds like more of the same to me with the premise being that the Palestinians wishing to 'return' are not getting true return as clearly spelled out by international law, but rather a shell game and the continuation of a very toxic status quo whereby one very racist Israel easily pushes more and more non-Jews- Muslims and Christians (ie Palestinians) into poverty and veritable prison camps because it insists on being the supposed "Jewish State" rather than a state of and for ALL its citizens, regardless of perceived religion or lack there of.
Posted by Anne Selden Annab
April 6, 2007

Resisting the Occupation on Good Friday

"Resisting the Occupation on Good Friday"


Date: 06 / 04 / 2007 Time: 14:33

Palestinian man strapped to a symbolic cross
during a demo in Umm Salamuna (MaanImages)
Bethlehem - Ma'an - The Israeli forces detained two peace activists for several hours and beat several others on Friday at noon during a non-violent demonstration against Israel's illegal separation wall in Al-Ma'sara, close to the village of Umm Salamuna, south of Bethlehem in the southern West Bank.

An eyewitness told Ma'an that dozens of Israeli leftist solidarity activists, local Palestinians, and foreigners demonstrated against the wall in the village. One Palestinian man was strapped to a symbolic cross as part of the demonstration, which took place on Good Friday, when Christians remember the crucifixion of Jesus Christ.

The Israeli soldiers fiercely attacked the demonstrators, leading to the injury of five Palestinians. Two activists were arrested but the demonstration got stronger until they were released. The cross was forcibly dismantled by the Israeli forces.

Mazen Al-'Aza from the Palestinian Medical Relief Services (PMRS) added that the Israeli occupation forces attacked the PMRS teams by beating them while they were trying to give first aid to demonstrators who had been beaten by the Israeli soldiers.

The image “http://www.palestine-info.ru/img_generale/17/1705032101.gif” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.
Our words have a way of echoing out into either war or peace....

Comment No. 516569: Bassem Eid v Ali Abunimah, Should the Palestinians give up their full right of return?


USA

I totally believe in and support waging peace with the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, including but not limited to FULLY respecting the Palestinian refugees right of return.... true return.

It is the civilized thing to do- honor promises, fair and just laws- real democracy- honor every family- every home- every child... true community.

Honor Palestine past, present and future...

True return

& true community with full and equal rights .... it really is the best way to wage a reasonable and realistic peace with security and justice for ALL.

POSTED IN RESPONCE TO
http://commentisfree.guardian.co.uk/take_two/2007/04/bassem_eid_v_ali_abunimah.html

Bassem Eid v Ali Abunimah

Should the Palestinians give up their full right of return?


Regarding- Cherokee official resigns after anti-semitic comments Planning commissioner said Israel should be abolished on personal Web site- AJC 4-5-7

RE: Cherokee official resigns after anti-semitic comments Planning commissioner said Israel should be abolished on personal Web site
http://www.ajc.com/services/content/metro/cherokee/stories/2007/04/04/0404metcherokeeisrael.html?cxtype=rss&cxsvc=7&cxcat=13

Dear Editor,

I vehemently disagree with your editorial decision to empower Zionist crimes by headlining controversial comments about Israel as 'antisemitic'.

Israel is a political entity- and a fantasy land for a bunch of religious fanatics- but it is not a religion. Israel's false claims to be "The Jewish State" are based on a cruel attempt to rid historic Palestine of indigenous non-Jews so that Zionists world wide can have a Jews-preferred secular/religious playground.

Israel as is, is an investment in segregation and apartheid- institutionalized bigotry, an economic and a military crime on the people of Palestine that has been very costly to defend. All in all modern man made Israel is a very bad idea.

I totally agree with the American
Cherokee official who spoke out wisely and honestly about "
dismantling Israel as a way to achieve peace in the Middle East". And it should worry us all that Americans who dare speak out for Palestine are attacked and vilified- and pushed out of jobs. Quite the echo really of what racist Israel has been doing all along to the people of Palestine.

Sincerely,
Anne Selden Annab

April 5

Palestinian Child Day

Since the start of the Intifada in September 2000, not one Palestinian child has been left untouched by Israel's continued brutal occupation: children too young to walk or speak have been shot dead by Israeli forces, others have seen friends and family members killed or injured, watched as their homes have been destroyed and parents humiliated, been beaten and tortured and thrown into prison without charges or trial. Physically and psychologically, socially and educationally their young lives are systematically being destroyed. Such is the extent of the children's suffering that concepts which are usually key for child rights organisations, such as the right to play, seem like unattainable luxuries. It is impossible to begin discussing these entitlements when Palestinian children are methodically denied even their most basic right: the right to life and personal security. - DCI-Palestine

Defence for Children International - Palestine Section

Playgrounds for Palestine

April 9

Deir Yassin Massacre (1948)

"Members of the underground Jewish terrorist group, the Irgun, led by Menachem Begin, who was to become the Israeli prime minister in 1977, entered the peaceful Arab village of Deir Yassin, massacred 250 men, women, children and the elderly, and stuffed many of the bodies down wells. There were also reports of rapes and mutilations. The Irgun was joined by the Jewish terrorist group, the Stern Gang, led by Yitzhak Shamir, who subsequently succeeded Begin as prime minister of Israel in the early '80s, and also by the Haganah, the militia under the control of David Ben Gurion. The Irgun, the Stern Gang and the Haganah later joined to form the Israeli Defense Forces. Their tactics have not changed." (by William Martin)

The Deir Yassin Massacre

The 1948 Massacre At Deir Yassin Revisited

Deir Yassin Remembered

letters

Second-class citizens in their own country

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/main.jhtml?xml=/opinion/2007/04/04/do0404.xml

Dear Sir,

THANK YOU !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

It is a relief to see a real pro-people/ pro democracy/ pro basic human rights- pro-Palestinian commentary!

Second-class citizens in their own country ( by Mike Smith) is a crucial aspect of the situation that is